Skip to main content

Is a Neighbourhood Plan right for you?

Whilst Neighbourhood Plans are a powerful tool for shaping how a community will grow, they are not the only option. This article explores the questions you should ask before deciding if a Neighbourhood Plan is right for your area, and discusses some alternative ways to participate in the planning process.

Is a Neighbourhood Plan right for you?

Neighbourhood Plans have been around for some time now, and most Parish & Town Councils will at some point have asked themselves whether they should prepare a Neighbourhood Plan. To answer this question, it is necessary to consider whether a Neighbourhood Plan is the right 'tool' for the job - crucially:

What does the community want to achieve, and is a Neighbourhood Plan the best way of delivering this?

You may not know what local people think are the biggest issues affecting their area. It is a good idea to carry out some community engagement exercises to find out what issues are affecting local people and how they would like to see the area improve.

Once you have an understanding of the issues affecting your area, you will be far better placed to decide if a Neighbourhood Plan is right for your area - or if some alternative approach or response is more suitable.

Neighbourhood Plan process

Neighbourhood Plans must follow a strict legal process. They require the input of a good deal of time and resources - even the most organised and motivated parish council will probably take roughly two years to write a Neighbourhood Plan.

Neighbourhood Plans are normally prepared by groups of volunteers who give up their time to write the plan. In addition, there are costs involved relating to printing, organising consultation events and often technical support from planning consultants - fortunately the government offers grant funding to neighbourhood planning groups.

Neighbourhood Plans operate within some very strict parameters. They must be about planning issues only, and therefore may not address broader community aspirations. Crucially, the plan must achieve 'general conformity' with the strategic policies of the Development Plan, which for some communities can be difficult to accept.

Alternatives to Neighbourhood Plans

Use the menu to explore some alternative options available to communities to enable them to engage in the planning process.

Respond to formal consultation

Every planning application is subject to a period of consultation and Parish & Town Councils are  routinely invited to comment on planning applications in their area. Most Parish & Town Councils hold a Planning Committee to enable development proposals to be discussed in an open forum, and formulate a response.

Individuals and other groups can also respond in writing to consultations on planning applications. Details of current consultations on planning applications are usually published in local newspapers, on the local planning authority's (LPA) website, and a Site Notice will normally be placed on the nearest lamp-post to the proposed site.

Many Local Planning Authorities, planning consultants, and organisations offer training and advice on how to effectively engage in the planning application process.

Pre-application engagement

It is good practice for developers to carry out community engagement prior to submitting a planning application. Parish & Town Councils can actively encourage applicants to undertake such engagement. For example, Parish & Town Councils could invite applicants to present their proposals at public meetings, facilitate workshops with local people, or provide an exhibition space in the town hall to display information about proposals.

Local Plan

The Local Plan is the main document which sets out planning policies across an area. Normally, planning applications which accord with the Local Plan should be approved, and those which conflict with it should be refused.

The strategic policies of the Local Plan set out how much development is required, and how this will be distributed across a local authority's area. Local Plans normally identify development sites for housing, employment and retail development; designate areas for protection; identify infrastructure requirements; and set out policies which explain what new development should be like.

The Local Plan is the most powerful planning document for an area. By informing what goes into the Local Plan, can directly affect how an area will grow.

Individuals and groups should participate in the formal stages of consultation during the preparation of the Local Plan. This involves providing written comments on the draft Local Plan.

Many local planning authorities (LPAs) will undertake additional community engagement and consultation exercises and workshops with Parish & Town Councils and other community groups. District/borough councillors are usually involved in the preparation of the Local Plan also.

In some areas, it may be possible for Parish & Town Councils (or other community groups) to directly collaborate with the LPA in writing the Local Plan. and its policies.

Some people may argue that if an up-to-date Local Plan says what the community wants it to say, there may be little need to write a Neighbourhood Plan.


Parish & Town Councils and other groups, either independently or in collaboration with the LPA, prepare guidance and evidence to inform planning applications and influence planning decisions.

Supplementary Planning Documents

Supplementary Planning Documents (SPDs) relate directly to one or more policies contained in the Local Plan. Typically, SPDs provide guidance for applicants and explain how planning policies will be applied. SPDs should not place excessive burdens on applicants.

For example, a 'Design' SPD might explain how new development should be designed, including the size, scale and form of development, and may provide examples of building materials which should be used in an area.

Village Design Statement

On the matter of design, Parish & Town Councils can prepare a 'Village Design Statement' (VDS) which describes the main characteristics of the design of built development in the locality. The VDS should can set out guidance to inform the preparation of planning applications. Where preparing a VDS, Parish & Town Councils should discuss this with the LPA. The main goal should be to get the LPA (the district or borough council or unitary authority) to formally adopt the VDS as a Supplementary Planning Document.

Technical Evidence

The 'evidence base' is a collection of technical documents and studies which inform the preparation of planning documents or determination of planning applications.

Evidence documents can relate to a wide range of planning issues, for example demographics, housing, employment, retail and environmental issues.

Communities can prepare or commission their own evidence, which can influence the LPA's decisions on planning applications. For example, some Parish & Town Councils have commissioned a Landscape Character Assessment (LCA) of their parish area. The LCA describes the local landscape and provides guidance for applicants. Some LPAs have been known to apply the findings of LCAs commissioned by Parish & Town Councils when determining planning applications.

Evidence can be prepared by local people, and does not necessarily require the involvement of experts. One idea could be to regularly undertake a 'health-check' of your local high street or town centre to see how well it is performing, what types of uses it contains, and how many buildings are vacant.


Parish & Town Councils can produce a 'Parish Plan'. This type of non-statutory plan pre-dates Neighbourhood Plans, but do not carry the same 'weight' in decision-making as they do not set out planning policies.

A key purpose of a Parish Plans is to influence the planning process, and they can inform and guide development in a similar way to SPDs and VDSs - they are a 'material consideration'. Some LPAs may formally adopt Parish Plans as SPDs.

Parish Plans are not subject to the same constraints or tests as Neighbourhood Plans. For example, Parish Plans have a wider scope than Neighbourhood Plans - they can address a wider range of issues affecting the community, rather than be just about planning.

Similarly to Neighbourhood Plans, Parish Plans should be informed by community engagement and should reflect the local community's vision and aspirations for how the area will grow in the future.


Conservation areas are designated for the purpose of managing and protecting the special architectural and historic interest of a place. According to Historic England, every LPA has at least one Conservation Area, and there are now more than 10,000 in England.

Conservation Area Appraisal & Management Plans identify the key characteristics of designated conservation areas. Communities can get involved in the preparation or review of Conservation Area Appraisal & Management Plans.

Many LPAs maintain a 'local list' of buildings or structures which are of local historic importance or architectural merit, but which do not necessarily qualify for designation as 'listed buildings'. Buildings or structures on the 'local list' usually benefit from additional protection through the planning process.

Communities can identify locally important buildings and structures and request the LPA place them on the local list.

In addition, Parish & Town Councils (or other groups) could, with the help of the LPA's Conservation Officer, apply for local buildings of special interest to be nationally listed by the Secretary of State.


An Article 4 direction removes certain permitted development rights in an area. This means that, where an Article 4 direction is in place, a planning application will be required for certain developments which might ordinarily not require a planning application.

For example, an Article 4 direction could require a planning application for replacing windows in a given area. This would normally be used to protect the historic character of the area, requiring 'traditional' style windows, rather than modern materials and styles, such as uPVC.

Other examples of Article 4 directions include the removal of permitted development rights for the change of family homes to Houses in Multiple Occupation.

Article 4 directions can be contentious, as it will mean people will need to apply for planning permission for things they might ordinarily expect to be able to do without submitting a planning application.

For this reason, Article 4 directions are generally used sparingly. However, a local authority may be more likely to set an Article 4 Direction, where it is the community's idea, and there is clear community support for it. Parish & Town Councils (or other community groups) therefore play an important role in demonstrating that an Article 4 direction is both needed and wanted by the community.


Neighbourhood Development Orders, Community Right to Build Orders and Local Development Orders grant planning permission for very specific types of development in a particular area.

Neighbourhood Development Orders and Community Right to Build Orders were introduced by the Localism Act, alongside Neighbourhood Plans.

Neighbourhood Development Orders (NDOs) are prepared by Parish & Town Councils or a Neighbourhood Forum and follow a similar process to Neighbourhood Plans - they are informed by consultation with the community and are subject to a process of independent examination and referendum.

NDOs grant planning permission for a certain type of development, enabling the development to be built without the need to submit a planning application and obtain planning permission. For example, NDOs could be used to grant planning permission for the development of housing, employment units or a local facility such as a shop, in a specific location.

A Community Right to Build Order (CRtBO) is similar to a NDO, but can be prepared by other community organisations - not just Parish & Town Councils and Neighbourhood Forums. Profits made as a result of the development should be used for the benefit of the community.

Locality's My Community site and the Neighbourhood Planning section of CPRE's site provide good explanations of, and guidance for preparing NDOs and CRtBOs.

Similarly, Local Development Orders (LDOs) provide planning permission for specific classes of development within a defined area, but are prepared by the LPA. Similarly to Local Plans, there may be opportunities to collaborate with the LPA in preparing an LDO.

Community groups should be mindful that to produce these 'development orders', the community organisation preparing the document will need to take on work (and likely incur costs) ordinarily met by the applicant - for example, in undertaking technical studies to demonstrate such a development is appropriate in planning terms. However, such options may be especially beneficial where the Parish & Town Council, Neighbourhood Forum or other community organisation is the developer.


Availability of affordable housing is a common concern for many communities. One established method to tackle this is through local people establishing a not-for-profit organisation called a 'Community Land Trust', often referred to as a 'CLT'.

CLTs can build and manage new affordable housing and other assets. CLTs act as long-term stewards of housing, ensuring that it remains genuinely affordable in perpetuity.

The National CLT Network's website provides advice, resources and several case study examples. Also see Locality's advice on community-led housing.

Discussion

The overwhelming strength of Neighbourhood Plans is that, once complete, they form part of the development plan for the area. Planning applications are judged against their policies, meaning Neighbourhood Plans directly influences how an area will grow over time.

As a direct alternative to writing a Neighbourhood Plan, collaborating with the LPA to ensure the policies of the Local Plan reflect the views of your community would, in theory, be of equal status.

This approach would likely be less resource-intensive than writing a Neighbourhood Plan. However, the Local Plan process is notoriously lengthy and your LPA will, at best, review its Local Plan once every five years. You can check the progress of Local Plans using my Local Plan checker.

Strictly speaking, a Neighbourhood Plan should only deal with planning issues, taking effect when determining planning applications and making planning decisions - although it is not uncommon to see references to other community projects and aspirations in Neighbourhood Plans.

Non-statutory plans, such as Parish Plans can address a wider range of issues and therefore may be more project-focused - for example identifying community projects and initiatives to be delivered by the Parish Council, local organisations and service providers.

Parish Plans are not bound by the same parameters as Neighbourhood Plans (for example, they do not need to comply with the basic conditions) and do not follow the same stringent process - a parish plan does not need to be examined or subject to referendum. Parish Plans remain a good option for those who want to think more broadly about the issues affecting their community, and also for groups who do not want to follow the Neighbourhood Plan process.

Neighbourhood Plans can identify sites for development and set requirements for what the development should be like. However, this does not guarantee that the development will actually take place. Neighbourhood Development Orders, Community Right to Build Orders and Local Development Orders effectively grant planning permission for a specific type of development, which could mean that development is more likely to be delivered.

Rather than simply planning for development, communities could deliver new development themselves. One established model is to set up a Community Land Trust to deliver affordable housing for the benefit of local people.

There are a range of options available to communities. Choosing the best option should be informed by a clear understanding of the community's views and aspirations.

Feedback

In this post, I've focused on established methods which are embedded in the planning system. I've intentionally not covered some of the more radical methods, such as protesting, petitions and lobbying - although these are options, their degree of success will likely vary significantly from case to case.

Neighbourhood Plans are important as, once made, form part of the Development Plan for the area, meaning they have considerable influence over development which can take place in an area. However, there is a time and a place for all of the options discussed in this post.

Have I missed anything? Comment below.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Housing Delivery Test 2019 Results Published

The Ministry for Housing, Communities and Local Government (MHCLG) has now published the latest results of its Housing Delivery Test (HDT), based on the number of new homes built in the period 2016 to 2019.

The HDT 2019 measurement for each council area is provided in the searchable table below.
How the Housing Delivery Test is calculated The HDT calculates the number of new homes built, as a percentage of the number of homes needed over the past three years. MHCLG re-calculates an HDT figure annually for every council area in England. The new 2019 measurement replaces the previous 2018 measurement.
Consequences of the Housing Delivery Test The purpose of the HDT is to hold local authorities to account over the supply of new housing.

Where the HDT shows the delivery of new homes has fallen below 95% of the district or borough's housing requirement over the previous three years, the council should prepare an Action Plan to assess the causes of under-delivery and identify actions to…

1,000th Neighbourhood Plan marks continued growth of neighbourhood planning

February 2020 saw an important milestone achieved, with the total number of approved Neighbourhood Plans reaching 1,000.
About the Planfinder data All Things Neighbourhood Planning's Planfinder app provides the data source for this blog post.

The Planfinder is a database of all Neighbourhood Plans which have successfully passed referendum. The Planfinder is maintained and updated regularly from ATNP's own research and monitoring of Neighbourhood Plan progress.

Joint Neighbourhood Plans (i.e. covering multiple parishes) and Neighbourhood Plans crossing a local authority boundary (i.e. forming part of the development plan in multiple local authority areas), are counted only once.

The Neighbourhood Plan data described in this post also includes Neighbourhood Development Orders and Community Right to Build Orders, as these are closely related to Neighbourhood Plans, follow a similar process in their preparation, and also fall under the 'umbrella' term of neighbourhood pla…

Neighbourhood Plan Review: Plans made in July 2019

Neighbourhood Plans provide a bespoke planning framework for the local area. No two plans are alike, although many have similar characteristics and address common themes. This post provides a short summary of those Neighbourhood Plans which successfully passed referendum in July 2019, highlighting the elements which make each plan locally specific and unique.

The purpose of this post is to celebrate the achievement of those communities in successfully preparing their Neighbourhood Plans, and to share the interesting ideas and policies for the benefit of others who are currently writing their plans. Links to the Neighbourhood Plans are provided throughout the post.
Navigate this post using the map July was a busy month, with a whopping 24 Neighbourhood Plans successfully passing referendum. To  make it easier to navigate this post, the location of the areas covered by each new Neighbourhood Plan are shown on the interactive map. Click on a marker to reveal a link to the plan's su…

Why the Middlewich Neighbourhood Plan failed

News that the Middlewich Neighbourhood Plan was rejected at referendum has spread rapidly across social media and has even been picked up by local and national press - see BBC article.

The story has garnered a lot of attention as it is highly unusual for a Neighbourhood Plan to be rejected. The Middlewich Neighbourhood Plan is only the third Neighbourhood Plan not to be supported by residents.

At the referendum held on 14 March 2019, the Neighbourhood Plan was rejected, albeit by a very slim margin of just 22 votes.
'No' Campaign Prior to the referendum, Labour town councillors led a campaign which encouraged local people to vote against the Neighbourhood Plan. 
Based on the literature shared by the campaign group, opposition to the Middlewich Neighbourhood Plan appears to be pointed at three key issues: Impacts on the town and its infrastructure of the overall scale of growth Middlewich is expected deliverDisagreement with the individual sites identified by the Neighbourhood …

The Neighbourhood Plan 'League Table'

My last blog post, 1,000th Neighbourhood Plan marks continued growth of neighbourhood planning, illustrates the growth of Neighbourhood Plans over recent years.

Exploring the data further, this blog post breaks down the total number of approved plans by Local Planning Authority area. Presenting the data in this way highlights the marked differences in the take up of neighbourhood planning in different areas. About the dataThe table (below) has been populated using data from my Planfinder app, and is based on the same dataset used in my 1,000th Neighbourhood Plan... blog post. The data includes plans which successfully passed referendum before the end of February 2020, therefore any plans which passed referendum over the past couple of weeks are not included - although you can find details of these on the Planfinder app.

The sum total of the number of approved plans shown in the table exceeds 1,000, as a small number of plans cross local planning authority boundaries and are therefore…

Review of Planning Appeal: The tricky task of planning for housing development - Wingerworth Neighbourhood Plan

I previously posted about why it is important to include policies and site allocations for housing, in order to "presumption-proof" your Neighbourhood Plan. A recent planning appeal (APP/R1038/W/17/3192255), which resulted in the granting of planning permission for 180 homes at Wingerworth, Derbyshire, illustrates the importance of making provision for housing development in a Neighbourhood Plan.

North East Derbyshire Council ranks settlements in a hierarchy. Wingerworth is located firmly in the middle of the hierarchy as a "Settlement with good levels of sustainability", so presumably has some merits as a location for housing development.

The Wingerworth Neighbourhood Plan (WNP) successfully passed the referendum stage in June 2018. The WNP includes a number of policies which relate to the provision of housing development, for example:

Policy W1 defines a settlement development limit around the built area of Wingerworth village, offering in principle support to de…

Updated Neighbourhood Plan Finder

Hundreds of Neighbourhood Plans have passed referendum and are being made across the country. It can therefore be tricky to keep track of which areas have plans in force.

All Things Neighbourhood Planning's Neighbourhood Plan Finder tool can help you quickly and simply locate Neighbourhood Plans.

Select a local authority area from the Neighbourhood Plan Finder to reveal a list of Neighbourhood Plans in force in the area.

The Neighbourhood Plan Finder includes web links to view and download the plan, therefore providing a comprehensive directory of Neighbourhood Plans.

For groups writing Neighbourhood Plans, the Neighbourhood Plan Finder can help you to find other local examples of plans which have completed the process. The Finder will also help applicants and decision-makers to locate Neighbourhood Plans which may affect their proposals.

Try the Neighbourhood Plan Finder now.

Alternatively, view locations with Neighbourhood Plans in force on the interactive map.

Just how big is an infill site? Appeal decision: Chinnor, Oxfordshire

An appeal decision initially caught my eye due to its surprising interpretation of 'infill development' -  but also raises some concerning issues around how Neighbourhood Plan policies are applied during the decision-making process.

The appeal relates to an application for the construction of up to 140 dwellings, new public open space, associated landscaping and site infrastructure on a 3.9ha site at Chinnor, Oxfordshire. The application was made by Persimmon Homes and initially refused by South Oxfordshire District Council. The appeal was allowed, meaning the Planning Inspector went against the district council's decision grant planning permission for the scheme. Details of the appeal can be found using the following reference APP/Q3115/W/17/3187058. Neighbourhood Plan & Development Plan Chinnor is a large village in Oxfordshire. The Chinnor Neighbourhood Plan (CNP) was 'made' in October 2017. When the appeal commenced, the Neighbourhood Plan was less than one…

Need for homes trumps valued landscapes. Review of appeal decision: Farnham Neighbourhood Plan

An appeal decision at land west of Folly Hill, Folly Hill, Farnham (appeal reference: APP/R3650/W/17/3171409) illustrates the delicate and complex issue of determining whether a Neighbourhood Plan is or is not 'out-of-date' and the effect this has on applying the 'tilted balance'.

The appeal decision was issued in December 2018, granting planning permission for 96 dwellings, including 38 affordable, with areas of open space, Suitable Alternative Natural Greenspace (SANGS); children’s play area; SuDS attenuation; highway works and a new access. 
The appeal site is located within the Borough of Waverley, Surrey, and the Farnham Neighbourhood Area. Development Plan The Farnham Neighbourhood Plan (FNP) was made in July 2017, and was therefore less than a year and a half old at the time the decision was issued.
During the course of the appeal, the Waverley Local Plan Part 1 (WLPP1) was adopted. This is, in effect, 'half' of a Local Plan setting out strategic polici…

How the Housing Delivery Test can affect Neighbourhood Plans

The Ministry for Housing, Communities and Local Government (MHCLG) has today published the results of the Housing Delivery Test (HDT).

**NEW - try my Housing Delivery Test Checker tool to see results for your area**

The HDT was first mooted by the Housing White Paper, back in February 2017. The HDT calculates the number of new homes built, as a percentage of the number of homes needed over the past three years. MHCLG has published a HDT figure for every council area in England, and indicates it will re-calculate the HDT annually.

The purpose of the HDT is to hold local authorities to account over the supply of new housing.

Where the HDT shows the delivery of new homes has fallen below 95% of the district or borough's housing requirement over the previous three years, the council should prepare an Action Plan to assess the causes of under-delivery and identify actions to increase delivery in future years.

Where the HDT shows a district's housing delivery is less than 85%, the c…