Skip to main content

Secretary of State overturns Planning Inspector's decision due to density concerns

Neighbourhood Plan, Secretary of State, Planning Inspector, densityNormally, planning appeals are determined by Planning Inspectors, but in some circumstances appeals may be 'recovered' for determination by the Secretary of State (SoS). The current SoS for Housing, Communities and Local Government is James Brokenshire MP.

In December 2018, the SoS issued a decision on a recovered appeal at Woburn Sands, Buckinghamshire. The proposal for residential development of up to 203 dwellings, a doctor’s surgery, open space and landscaping, together with pedestrian, cycle and vehicular access, was initially refused by Milton Keynes Council, and following appeal, granted permission by a Planning Inspector. However, the SoS recovered the appeal and overturned the Inspector's decision, dismissing the appeal.

Details of the case are available on the Planning Inspectorate's website, using case reference: APP/Y0435/W/17/3169314.

Appeal site & Neighbourhood Plan

The appeal site is a 15.2 hectare, greenfield site, located outside the development boundary of Woburn Sands - a small town, in close proximity of Milton Keynes.

A small part of the appeal site is located within the Woburn Sands Neighbourhood Area. The Woburn Sands Neighbourhood Plan (WSNP) was made in 2014, and places great importance on protecting the countryside setting, woodlands and footpath links. The WSNP  permits development outside the Development Boundary only in exceptional circumstances.

Planning History

Initially, the scheme was recommended for approval by an officer at Milton Keynes Council (MKC). The relevant policies were considered to be out of date as MKC was unable to demonstrate a five year supply of housing land. The officer therefore applied the NPPF's 'tilted balance', concluding that the scheme is sustainable and should be approved. However, the scheme was ultimately refused by MKC's Planning Committee, on the basis that the scheme is contrary to the WSNP (policy WS5), and is low-density and therefore not sustainable.

An appeal was submitted and a public inquiry was held in 2017. A Planning Inspector considered that, in the absence of a five year supply of housing land, the WSNP's policy to restrict development in the countryside should be afforded "very little weight".

The Planning Inspector assessed the impacts of the proposal, exploring a range of themes, such as the location of the site, density of the proposed scheme, character of the area and heritage.

The Planning Inspector concluded that the the scheme would deliver benefits, placing significant weight on the provision of market and affordable housing, which "would not only contribute to meeting the dearth in the provision identified, but also represent a step towards reducing the imbalance between jobs and housing that has arisen as a result of the failure of house-building to keep pace with local economic growth." The Planning Inspector granted planting permission, concluding that:

"...even in circumstances where an inspector were to conclude that the Council could demonstrate a 5-year supply of housing, the sustainability and other advantages could constitute material considerations sufficient to justify the grant of planning permission."

Clearly, there was little doubt in the Planning Inspector's mind in making his decision.

Secretary of State's Decision

The Secretary of State (SoS) recovered the appeal and reviewed the Inspector's decision..

Like the Planning Inspector, the SoS considered that the housing benefits of the scheme carry significant weight in favour of the proposal. The SoS noted the economic benefits, applying moderate weight in favour of the proposal.

The SoS considers that the low density of the scheme carries significant weight against the proposal. The low density of the scheme (just 16 dwellings per hectare) conflicts with policies in the development plan which promote higher densities, even when the character of the surrounding area is taking into account. Similarly, the Planning Inspector raised concerns with the density of the scheme, noting that land should be used as efficiently and effectively as possible.

Interestingly, the SoS considered that Milton Keynes Council does have a five year land supply. However, the SoS maintained that the WSNP policy to restrict development in the countryside is out-of-date. The SoS therefore applied only moderate weight to the appeal site's location in open countryside outside the development boundary.

In addition, the SoS considered the impact on the character of the area carries limited weight.

The Secretary of State considers that the proposal should be determined in accordance with the development plan, and therefore concluded that the appeal should be dismissed, and planning permission should be refused.


The Woburn Sands case is an interesting one. Firstly, it is somewhat surprising the SoS recovered the appeal in the first place. The Inspector's decision is a 'classic' example of the 'tilted balance' being applied in the absence of a five year housing land supply.

Secondly, it was no surprise that the Inspector considered the WSNP's development boundary to be out-of-date, as he had determined there to be a lack of a five year housing land supply. However, the SoS considers there is a five year land supply - but still treated the WSNP's development boundary as out-of-date. This highlights the inherent risk in carrying forward development boundaries from Local Plans - they can be determined to be 'out-of-date' and therefore have little effect.

Thirdly, and perhaps most surprising is the significant weight the SoS places on the 'density' of new housing, surpassing even the benefits of delivering new housing. Perhaps this gives some insight into what the government considers 'sustainable development' to mean. I would conclude from this that, Neighbourhood Plans should set out criteria-based policies which clearly and precisely explain the requirements which new development should meet to be sustainable and of high quality design.


Popular posts from this blog

Why the Middlewich Neighbourhood Plan failed

News that the Middlewich Neighbourhood Plan was rejected at referendum has spread rapidly across social media and has even been picked up by local and national press - see BBC article.

The story has garnered a lot of attention as it is highly unusual for a Neighbourhood Plan to be rejected. The Middlewich Neighbourhood Plan is only the third Neighbourhood Plan not to be supported by residents.

At the referendum held on 14 March 2019, the Neighbourhood Plan was rejected, albeit by a very slim margin of just 22 votes.
'No' Campaign Prior to the referendum, Labour town councillors led a campaign which encouraged local people to vote against the Neighbourhood Plan. 
Based on the literature shared by the campaign group, opposition to the Middlewich Neighbourhood Plan appears to be pointed at three key issues: Impacts on the town and its infrastructure of the overall scale of growth Middlewich is expected deliverDisagreement with the individual sites identified by the Neighbourhood …

Latest stats show continued increase in house-building

Chart: All Things Neighbourhood Planning
Data source: Live tables on housebuilding: new build dwellings (Table 209), MHCLG

The Ministry for Housing, Communities and Local Government has today published its latest data on house building in the United Kingdom. The graph shows the number of dwellings completed by financial year in England. Data is also available for the other home nations. However, Neighbourhood Planning is a feature of the English planning system only.

In 2017/18, there were more than 160,500 new homes constructed. - the highest rate of development since the financial crisis of 2007-08. As illustrated in the graph, the data shows a steady increase in number of homes built each year since the low-point of 2012-13, where less than 108,000 homes were built. 

The rate of development in 2017/18 is comparable to the period 2004 - 2006. Assuming this trend of increasing development rates continues into the current financial year, the number of homes constructed in 2018/19 could po…

Neighbourhood Plan Review: Plans made in July 2019

Neighbourhood Plans provide a bespoke planning framework for the local area. No two plans are alike, although many have similar characteristics and address common themes. This post provides a short summary of those Neighbourhood Plans which successfully passed referendum in July 2019, highlighting the elements which make each plan locally specific and unique.

The purpose of this post is to celebrate the achievement of those communities in successfully preparing their Neighbourhood Plans, and to share the interesting ideas and policies for the benefit of others who are currently writing their plans. Links to the Neighbourhood Plans are provided throughout the post.
Navigate this post using the map July was a busy month, with a whopping 24 Neighbourhood Plans successfully passing referendum. To  make it easier to navigate this post, the location of the areas covered by each new Neighbourhood Plan are shown on the interactive map. Click on a marker to reveal a link to the plan's su…

Just how big is an infill site? Appeal decision: Chinnor, Oxfordshire

An appeal decision initially caught my eye due to its surprising interpretation of 'infill development' -  but also raises some concerning issues around how Neighbourhood Plan policies are applied during the decision-making process.

The appeal relates to an application for the construction of up to 140 dwellings, new public open space, associated landscaping and site infrastructure on a 3.9ha site at Chinnor, Oxfordshire. The application was made by Persimmon Homes and initially refused by South Oxfordshire District Council. The appeal was allowed, meaning the Planning Inspector went against the district council's decision grant planning permission for the scheme. Details of the appeal can be found using the following reference APP/Q3115/W/17/3187058. Neighbourhood Plan & Development Plan Chinnor is a large village in Oxfordshire. The Chinnor Neighbourhood Plan (CNP) was 'made' in October 2017. When the appeal commenced, the Neighbourhood Plan was less than one…

Putting Health & Wellbeing at the Heart of Neighbourhood Planning

The planning system's origins can be traced back to public health policies from the nineteenth century. Increases in population and the growth of towns created public health problems, and early legislation focused on creating sanitary conditions.

There is a sense that in recent decades planning has lost its way with health, yet our modern environments continue to have profound effects on our health and well-being. In the blog post What stops us from creating healthier places? author Rachel Toms notes that overall, the planning system has done a good job of designing infectious diseases out of the places in which people live, but has "inadvertently contributed to sedentary lifestyles, mental distress and social isolation".

Whilst the planning system has cured the public health problems of the industrial revolution, it faces a new set of public health challenges for the modern era.

In this post, I make the case for prioritising health and wellbeing through Neighbourhood P…

Appeal granted in countryside despite Five Year Land Supply - Shinfield Neighbourhood Plan

Through a recent appeal decision, a Planning Inspector has granted outline planning permission for up to 55 dwellings and 'Suitable Alternative Natural Greenspace' (SANG) at land at Parklands, east of Basingstoke Road, Spencers Wood, Wokingham.

The decision was issued on 28th February 2019, under appeal reference APP/X0360/W/18/3204133.

The appeal site is located between two villages, Three Mile Cross and Spencers Wood. The scheme proposes two areas of development adjoining each of the villages, separated by an area of open space - a 'SANG'.
Shinfield Neighbourhood Plan The Shinfield Neighbourhood Plan (SNP) was made in February 2017. Policy 1 of the SNP addresses the location of development:

In Shinfield Parish, development within the Development Limits..., will be supported; development adjacent to the Development Limits will only be supported where the benefits of the development outweigh its adverse impacts. 

'Development limits' are a very common planning …

Neighbourhood Planning and Community Health and Wellbeing - Briefing Note for NALC

I have teamed up with the National Association of Local Councils (NALC) to author a briefing note on Neighbourhood Planning and Community Health and Wellbeing.

The briefing note illustrates how Neighbourhood Plans can actively contribute to improving health and wellbeing in their communities, and draws on recent examples of neighbourhood plan policies. Neighbourhood Plans can tackle issues of health and wellbeing in lots of different ways, as explained in the briefing note, and is something I will be making the case for in future blog posts.

A pdf version of the briefing note is available to view and download below. Further advice on neighbourhood planning is also available from NALC's website.

Neighbourhood Plan Review: Plans Made in September 2019

This post explores Neighbourhood Plans which successfully passed referendum in September 2019, highlighting elements which make each plan locally specific and unique. The following Neighbourhood Plans passed referendum in September 2019:
Bawtry Neighbourhood Plan (Doncaster Council)Brackenfield Neighbourhood Plan (North East Derbyshire District Council)Chelford Neighbourhood Plan (Cheshire East Council)Congresbury Neighbourhood Plan (North Somerset Council)Glentworth Neighbourhood Plan (West Lindsey District Council)Hanslope Neighbourhood Plan (Milton Keynes Council)Hullavington Neighbourhood Plan (Wiltshire Council)Huntingdon Neighbourhood Plan (Huntingdonshire District Council)Misterton Neighbourhood Plan (Bassetlaw District Council)Moreton, Bobbingworth and the Lavers Neighbourhood Plan (Epping Forest District Council)Sedgefield Neighbourhood Plan (Durham County Council)Sedgeford Neighbourhood Plan (Kings Lynn & West Norfolk District Council)Sid Valley Neighbourhood Plan (Sidmo…

Essential reading for Neighbourhood Planners

Through my site I have attempted to explain the neighbourhood planning process, and provide regular blog posts on the latest issues affecting neighbourhood planning. But where can you go to find out more?

In this article I attempt to summarise where you should go for the most useful information and guidance, and where you can find funding and support for writing a Neighbourhood Plan.
Locality Toolkits and Guidance Locality administer the government's current programme of support for neighbourhood planning groups, and Locality's site should be your first port of call when writing a Neighbourhood Plan.
Locality has produced an excellent series of 'toolkits & guidance' on a range of issues to assist the preparation of neighbourhood plans. It is difficult to understate how valuable Locality's guides are for budding neighbourhood planners. Be sure you don't miss: The Neighbourhood Plans Roadmap 2018 by Dave …